TYPICAL 
The Holiday Issue · His side here. Her side: Breaking up before the holidays: cruel or kind? at Typical Female.Pick a side ↓
Here's one of the most selfish things a man can do in November, and from the outside it looks like kindness: stay.
Three Novembers ago, I knew. Not suspected. Knew. The relationship was over and had been for a while. And I did what a lot of guys do: I looked at the calendar, saw Thanksgiving with her family, then the holiday party, then New Year's, and decided to wait until January.
I told myself it was kindness. It wasn't. I wasn't sparing her the holidays. I was sparing myself the conversation.
I wasn't sparing her the holidays. I was sparing myself the conversation.
What waiting actually costs
Two months of pretending is a long time. I went to her family's Thanksgiving and shook her dad's hand knowing I'd never see him again. I bought a Christmas gift that meant nothing. She could feel it. People always can. When I finally ended it in January, she said, "I knew in November." So she'd spent the holidays waiting too, except she didn't know for what.
The season is heavy enough on its own. The American Psychological Association's 2023 poll found 89% of adults say something causes them stress during the holidays, 41% say their stress increases, and 43% say it gets in the way of enjoying the season. A relationship you've already left in your head is one more weight you're asking her to carry without telling her.
Cuffing season is not a reason
"Cuffing season" is the joke that you pair up when it gets cold so you're not alone for the holidays. Fine. But staying cuffed after it's over isn't romance. It's using someone as a seat filler.
Staying after it's over isn't romance. It's using someone as a seat filler.
The case for waiting, taken seriously
There are real reasons to hold off, and I won't pretend otherwise. If her father is in the hospital, if she just lost her job, if you're about to fly to her grandmother's ninetieth, ending it that week can be cruel in a way that has nothing to do with honesty. Timing matters. A breakup two days before a family holiday can turn a painful private conversation into a public event.
So the question isn't "now or January." It's "am I waiting for a reason that's about her, or a reason that's about me?" If it's about her, set a date and keep it. If it's about you, you already know the answer.
Three situations, three calls
You're booked to fly to her family's on Wednesday. If you're certain, tell her before the trip, not at the gate. Offer to cover any change fees. Let her decide what her family hears.
She's hosting her first Thanksgiving. If she's about to cook for twelve, a few more days won't change the outcome. Talk the following week, and in the meantime, don't make promises at the table you know you won't keep.
You're not sure. Then it isn't a breakup decision yet. It's a conversation. "I've been feeling far from us, and I want to talk about it" is a fair thing to say in November.
How to do it with care
Do it in person, privately, and not on the holiday itself or the night before. Don't do it the day before travel. Be clear and short: the decision is made, it's not a negotiation. Don't promise friendship you won't follow through on. If you're expected at her family's table, cancel cleanly and let her decide what to tell them. And then leave her alone.
If you're the one on the other end
If someone ends things with you in November, the season can feel like a spotlight on the empty seat. Lean on people who'd want to hear from you. Say yes to the invitation you'd normally skip. And if it gets darker than heartbreak, please reach out.
If the holidays are bringing up thoughts of suicide or self-harm, you don't have to wait for it to pass. In the U.S., call or text 988, the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, any time. You can also text HOME to 741741 to reach the Crisis Text Line. See our full list of crisis resources.
Her side, whether breaking up before the holidays is cruel or kind, is at Typical Female: Breaking up before the holidays: cruel or kind?.
Frequently asked questions
Is it wrong to break up before the holidays?
Not if you're sure. Staying for weeks in a relationship you've already left asks the other person to spend the season inside something that isn't real. Avoid the holiday itself and the day before travel, and be kind about timing when there's a genuine crisis.
How do you break up with someone before Thanksgiving?
In person, in private and not on the holiday or right before a trip. Be clear and short, don't negotiate, let them decide what to tell their family and give them space afterward.
What is cuffing season?
Slang for the colder months, when people are said to pair up so they're not alone for the holidays. It's a joke, not a reason to stay in a relationship that's over.
What should I do if I get dumped right before the holidays?
Tell a few people you trust, say yes to invitations you'd normally skip and plan your hardest days in advance. If the heartbreak turns into thoughts of self-harm, call or text 988 in the U.S., or text HOME to 741741.
Your turn
Kinder to end it now, or crueler than waiting until January? Pick a side below. If you've been on either end of a holiday breakup, we'd like to hear it.
Pick a side
Breaking up right before the holidays is:
Tap one to get your share card. Your pick stays on this device; it is not a vote tally.
I took a side
The card links back to this piece. It is not a vote tally.
Her side · Typical FemaleBreaking up before the holidays: cruel or kind?Read her take ↗
- Take the quiz: How typical is your Thanksgiving?
- Add your take to the Debate of the Month: Whose family gets Thanksgiving?
- Tell us your story. 18+, anonymous if you want, read by an editor.
More from the Holiday Issue
Sources
- American Psychological Association, holiday season stress poll, Nov 2023 (n=2,061). 89% of U.S. adults say something causes them stress during the holidays; 41% say their stress increases; 43% say holiday stress interferes with their ability to enjoy the season.